News:

For advertising inquiries or help with registration or other issues, you may contact us by email at support @ harleytechtalk.com

Main Menu

Exhaust question: OEM headers vs true duals vs 2-1?

Started by Finn, August 11, 2015, 10:19:48 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

Finn

Ladies and gentlemen,

my question today is if everything else is to be kept the same but only exhaust is changed from

OEM headers with slip-ons to true dual headers with same slip-ons
or
OEM headers with same slip-ons to 2-1 exhaust such as Supermeg
or
true dual headers with same slip-ons to 2-1 exhaust such as Supermeg

How does torque and hp change with each change, increase or decrease? Will true duals and/or 2-1 bring or lose numbers compared to OEM headers?

I'm after info of which exhaust would give me the most torque in my FLHR.
-83 GS1000G | -84 GSX1100EF | -97 FLHR | -98 FLSTS | -99 R1100RT

FLTRI

Quote from: KaritheFinn on August 11, 2015, 10:19:48 AM
Ladies and gentlemen,

my question today is if everything else is to be kept the same but only exhaust is changed from

OEM headers with slip-ons to true dual headers with same slip-ons
or
OEM headers with same slip-ons to 2-1 exhaust such as Supermeg
or
true dual headers with same slip-ons to 2-1 exhaust such as Supermeg

How does torque and hp change with each change, increase or decrease? Will true duals and/or 2-1 bring or lose numbers compared to OEM headers?

I'm after info of which exhaust would give me the most torque in my FLHR.
Freeflowing (open) slipon mufflers with the stock headpipe (w/cat) will preserve bottom end torque and power increase all running areas. That's the most economic way to get to where you want to be.
Don't forget to get it tuned for best running (cooler) as well.
Bob
Bob
The best we've experienced is the best we know
Always keep eyes and mind open

stogieluvr60

Quote from: KaritheFinn on August 11, 2015, 10:19:48 AM
Ladies and gentlemen,

my question today is if everything else is to be kept the same but only exhaust is changed from

OEM headers with slip-ons to true dual headers with same slip-ons
or
OEM headers with same slip-ons to 2-1 exhaust such as Supermeg
or
true dual headers with same slip-ons to 2-1 exhaust such as Supermeg

How does torque and hp change with each change, increase or decrease? Will true duals and/or 2-1 bring or lose numbers compared to OEM headers?

I'm after info of which exhaust would give me the most torque in my FLHR.

What is the current state of your Road Glide? Stock other than exhaust or what? I see you have had a 124 in the past so what the deal with this ride?

Finn

My current exhaust is OEM headers with Hooker Tuned Flow slip-ons.

Pondering whether to go with Fullsac true dual kit (bargain at around 170 bucks) or with Supermeg 2-1 with my mild build.

I would be hesitant to make either of above changes to my current exhaust if it would move torque up or make lower tq numbers.
-83 GS1000G | -84 GSX1100EF | -97 FLHR | -98 FLSTS | -99 R1100RT

q1svt

The old style head pipe are dated.

Most 2-1 are design for mid-to-top end

True duals for stock to mild builds are good option

2-1-2 are good for stock, mild and performance builds
Greatest obstacle to discovery is not ignorance, it's the illusion of knowledge.

Admiral Akbar

Quote from: KaritheFinn on August 11, 2015, 10:19:48 AM
Ladies and gentlemen,

my question today is if everything else is to be kept the same but only exhaust is changed from

OEM headers with slip-ons to true dual headers with same slip-ons
or
OEM headers with same slip-ons to 2-1 exhaust such as Supermeg
or
true dual headers with same slip-ons to 2-1 exhaust such as Supermeg

How does torque and hp change with each change, increase or decrease? Will true duals and/or 2-1 bring or lose numbers compared to OEM headers?

I'm after info of which exhaust would give me the most torque in my FLHR.

Yes

Yes

FLTRI

Quote from: KaritheFinn on August 11, 2015, 10:45:22 AM
My current exhaust is OEM headers with Hooker Tuned Flow slip-ons.
What year is this bike? Supermeg w/10 discs and closed end cap with a good tune will work no matter what year?
Hooker Tuned Flow slipons were not The best choice based on tuning bikes with these muffs.
If you have an early stage 1-2 bike the stock "y" pipe work adequately.
If you have a 09-up touring bike then free flowing (open) slipons with the cat in place will work very well.
Bob
The best we've experienced is the best we know
Always keep eyes and mind open

Finn

-83 GS1000G | -84 GSX1100EF | -97 FLHR | -98 FLSTS | -99 R1100RT

Bigbluff

I suspect that with the stock cam/heads, it won't matter much. Probably detectable on a real dyno, but doubtful on the "butt dyno." For me, true duals sound the best no matter what they are on. On an otherwise stock bike I'd go with true duals. Depending on how much it's built after that and how much difference it would actually make would determine how much of the sound quality I would be willing to give up for performance. For most performance builds, true duals are the bottom of the barrel when it comes to performance.

Others will probably tell me I'm all wrong...and I probably am, but opinions are like (_o_)... Everyone has one and they usually stink...including mine... :argue:
In all that time he was riding through the desert he could have named that horse

glens

Quote from: FLTRI on August 11, 2015, 10:54:44 AM
If you have a 09-up touring bike then free flowing (open) slipons with the cat in place will work very well.

Bob, including '09 itself in that group it should be specified that a California (maybe International?) head pipe with catalyst is required.  Stuck where you are you might not have ever seen a 49-state '09 pipe?  I know you know, but as long as I'm jabbering, the 49-state pipe looked the same externally (except for the more upstream, larger O2 bungs) but was just an empty can where the cat is otherwise.

With that on the table, does your recommendation apply to them as well?

My experience is (even currently) that 2" core Rush slip-ons, everything else bone stock, works very well with the '09+ catalyst head pipe.  Obviously, in most every case an individual tune would be beneficial, but in my two experiences so far with the cat, pre-tuning interface, things don't change enough to cause any sort of running issues with the factory calibration.

FLTRI

Got me Glen! Yep 09 was the bastard year exhaust because they stayed with the 18mm sensors with a cat in California and then filled the box for the rest of the country the following year and move the sensors downstream and upgraded to the 12mm mini sensors.
Just don't know why the MOCO would make and intermediate pipe unless the mini sensors hadn't got approval from the EPA in time?
Bob
The best we've experienced is the best we know
Always keep eyes and mind open

Nowhereman

Every time I have had the bug to swap out pipes, I always keep going back to a 2 into 1 for the best performance.
Low end to high end, nothing works better for the street or almost all racing applications.
Only time I could see a 2 into 1 not be the best would be in a fuel application where max HP at the high end (for drag racing) is what counts.
- From Nowhere in particular

jmorton10

Quote from: Bigbluff on August 11, 2015, 12:38:47 PM
For me, true duals sound the best no matter what they are on.

I definitely agree with that.

Although I am now running a Dragula for performance, I think the all time best sounding pipes ever (other than an old shovel with drag pipes) are the Rinehart True Duals I used to run.

~John
HC 124", Dragula, Pingel air shift W/Dyna Shift Minder & onboard compressor, NOS

PkgMan

on my 2012 FLTRX, its completely stock other than a set of Thunder header slipon mufflers.  Bike runs fantastic and sounds great

PkgMan

Matt C

Quote from: Nowhereman on August 11, 2015, 11:49:50 PM
Every time I have had the bug to swap out pipes, I always keep going back to a 2 into 1 for the best performance.
Low end to high end, nothing works better for the street or almost all racing applications.
Only time I could see a 2 into 1 not be the best would be in a fuel application where max HP at the high end (for drag racing) is what counts.
:agree: 2->1 will outperform the rest of them, hands down. Now, as far as sound goes? That's a personal preference.
(For me, personally; The best sounding pipe is the one that performs the best.)

Nowhereman

Quote from: MCE on August 12, 2015, 08:42:08 AM
Quote from: Nowhereman on August 11, 2015, 11:49:50 PM
Every time I have had the bug to swap out pipes, I always keep going back to a 2 into 1 for the best performance.
Low end to high end, nothing works better for the street or almost all racing applications.
Only time I could see a 2 into 1 not be the best would be in a fuel application where max HP at the high end (for drag racing) is what counts.
:agree: 2->1 will outperform the rest of them, hands down. Now, as far as sound goes? That's a personal preference.
(For me, personally; The best sounding pipe is the one that performs the best.)

I'd have to agree completely. :agree:
- From Nowhere in particular

No Cents

 I also  :agree:
2n1 work best on almost every application unless you want the top hp peak #'s...then a 2n2 drag pipe wins hands down.

Ray
08 FLHX my grocery getter, 124ci, wfolarry 110" heads, Burns pipe, 158/152 sae

Finn

I asked today my trusty parts guy about the Supermeg. My price is pretty much even 1000,- Euros ie. USD 1100,-.  :doh:

I think I will have another look at Fullsac true dual conversion kit or other true duals headers.  :embarrassed:
-83 GS1000G | -84 GSX1100EF | -97 FLHR | -98 FLSTS | -99 R1100RT

strokerjlk

I wouldn't change the exhaust you have now .
My best 88 ci stage one was with the same exhaust you have now .
Those mufflers work good at your level, as does the stock head pipe .
A scientific theory summarizes a hypothesis
repeated testing establishes theory

Nowhereman

Try this.
Pick up a used Pro pipe and throw away the collector / muffler.
Then pick up a Burns Stainless Megaphone muffler to match the Pro Pipe  merge opening.
Weld or clamp it on and go have some serious fun.
Used Pro pipes are cheap and the Burns unit run around $300.00
You will drop some 10 to 15 lbs and let your bike breathe much better.
- From Nowhere in particular

FLTRI

Quote from: Nowhereman on August 12, 2015, 12:57:00 PM
Try this.
Pick up a used Pro pipe and throw away the collector / muffler.
Then pick up a Burns Stainless Megaphone muffler to match the Pro Pipe  merge opening.
Weld or clamp it on and go have some serious fun.
Used Pro pipes are cheap and the Burns unit run around $300.00
You will drop some 10 to 15 lbs and let your bike breathe much better.
All that to get a good running, mild build, Bagger? :scratch:$$$
Bob
The best we've experienced is the best we know
Always keep eyes and mind open

Jonny Cash

Accurate information is expensive, rare and difficult to find!

Nowhereman

Quote from: FLTRI on August 12, 2015, 01:07:03 PM
Quote from: Nowhereman on August 12, 2015, 12:57:00 PM
Try this.
Pick up a used Pro pipe and throw away the collector / muffler.
Then pick up a Burns Stainless Megaphone muffler to match the Pro Pipe  merge opening.
Weld or clamp it on and go have some serious fun.
Used Pro pipes are cheap and the Burns unit run around $300.00
You will drop some 10 to 15 lbs and let your bike breathe much better.
All that to get a good running, mild build, Bagger? :scratch:$$$
Bob

Not much, Pro pipes on Ebay go for around 150 bucks.
Burns unit another 300.00
That combo would be better than almost everything on the market.
- From Nowhere in particular

1FSTRK

Quote from: q1svt on August 11, 2015, 10:48:20 AM
The old style head pipe are dated.

Most 2-1 are design for mid-to-top end

True duals for stock to mild builds are good option

2-1-2 are good for stock, mild and performance builds

Great post
The old school thinking went out the window when the 2-1-2 and x pipes came out.
The key is the additional muffler volume of these new systems.
"Never hang on to a mistake just because you spent time or money making it."

gabbyduffy

        Does the 09 catless head pipe out perform the 13 cat in head pipe both with a set of free flowing mufflers?
Duffy 216-633-8541 eastern time zone.